GOVERNSUTRA AI · INTERNAL REVIEW AID

GovernSutra AI — Independent Audit Report

Decision: ASSURANCE_CHECKS_PASSED_HUMAN_REVIEW_REQUIRED
ASSURANCE_CHECKS_PASSED_HUMAN_REVIEW_REQUIRED means every executed check behaved as specified. It is never an approval, certification or compliance statement. Any failed check gives ASSURANCE_CHECKS_FAILED. Skipped checks are listed, not counted as passes.
Tool
GovernSutra AI 0.2.1
Integrity
SHA-256 seal verified (3649fb91e69440c2…)
Recorded
2026-11-19T19:01:57.211Z
Environment
Node v24.15.0 · win32/x64
Assurance checks
30 passed · 0 failed · 1 skipped of 31
Inventory
agents: 20 · skills: 26 · rules: 10 · workflows: 8 · hostAdapters: 9 · runtimeDependencies: 0
Independence statement
Automated self-assurance: the tool exercises its own code on hostile inputs. It is not a third-party audit. A truly independent assessment needs a qualified human outside the project.

Assurance checks (each runs the real code on a hostile or negative-control input)

IDCheckExpectedObservedResult
A01Altered audit event is detectedchain invalidvalid=false, issues=1pass
A02Deleted audit event breaks the chainchain invalidvalid=false, events=1pass
A03Evidence path traversal is refusederror "inside the workspace"Evidence file must be inside the workspace rootpass
A04Evidence symlink escaping the workspace is refusederror mentioning symlinkEvidence symlink resolves outside the workspacepass
A05Secret-like evidence paths are refused (.env, .pem)both refusedSecret-like paths cannot be attached as evidence; Secret-like paths cannot be attached as evidencepass
A06Oversized evidence (>2 MiB) is refusederror "exceeds 2 MiB"Evidence file exceeds 2 MiB limitpass
A07Scanner never reads .env valuescanary string absent from outputcanary leaked=falsepass
A08Credentials in dependency URLs are redactedpassword absentleaked=falsepass
A09Manifest symlinked outside the repository is skippedzero candidates + notehost cannot create symlinks without privilegeskipped
A10Unknown risk inputs are never scored lowband not low, 6 unknown factorsscore=60, band=high, unknown=6pass
A11Control marked verified without evidence fails GOV-004GOV-004 failfailpass
A12File presence alone is never verificationGOV-004 not passunknownpass
A13Expired exception reopens the findingrule fails againfailpass
A14An agent cannot approve its own exceptionexception invalid, rule still failsfailpass
A15Valid human exception is recorded as exception-approved, not passexception-approvedexception-approvedpass
A16Reports escape HTML and Markdown injectionno raw tag, link syntax escapedhtmlRawTag=falsepass
A17A fully declared system is still never auto-approveddecision HUMAN_REVIEW_REQUIREDHUMAN_REVIEW_REQUIREDpass
A18Report text contains no unqualified compliance claimno "is compliant"/"certified" phrasingclaim found=falsepass
A19Local API: auth, read-only, no CORS, loopback401 / 405 / 403 / 127.0.0.1noAuth=401 POST=405 origin=403 ok=200 bind=127.0.0.1pass
A20Server refuses weak tokenserrorA token of at least 24 characters is requiredpass
A21Manifest with wrong integrity digest is rejectedstatus digest-mismatch, no systemdigest-mismatchpass
A22Correct manifest digest is verified; invalid manifest is rejectedvalid + invalid{"a.json":"valid","b.json":"invalid","c.json":"invalid-json"}pass
A23Manifest count is bounded (200 max)200 read + note200 readpass
A24Imported manifest never overwrites an existing systemskipped, not replacedimported=0 skipped=1pass
A25Lockfile yields the exact resolved version with a JSON pointerversion 4.2.1 + pointer4.2.1 /packages/node_modules~1openaipass
A26Model version change triggers re-reviewmodel-change-review trigger1 change, triggers=model-change-reviewpass
A27Host adapter install refuses to overwrite without --forcerefusal then successRefusing to overwrite C:\Users\VATSAL~1\AppData\Local\Temp\govsut-audit-ide-19QxFA\.cursor\rules\governsutra.mdc (+71 more); pass --force afpass
A28Host name path traversal is refusedUnsupported host adapterUnsupported host adapter. See docs/IDE_COMPATIBILITY.mdpass
A29Sealed report detects later editsverifySeal false after editintact=true, afterEdit=falsepass
A30Shipped inventory matches claims (20 agents, 26 skills, 10 rules, 8 workflows)counts equalagents=20 skills=26 rules=10 workflows=8pass
A31Every agent and skill file states its boundaries (no compliance claims, human authority)all files mention human/unknown rule46 files checked, 0 without boundary languagepass

Sample outputs

CapabilityResult
assess (fixture AI-SYS-001)risk 42/100 (moderate); rules pass=9 fail=0 unknown=1 n/a=0; decision HUMAN_REVIEW_REQUIRED
scan (fixtures/sample-repo)4 candidates from 4 allowlisted files; notes: 1
diff (tool permission added)1 change; triggers tool-permission-review
audit chain (fixture workspace)valid=true, events=1

Evidence tiers

ArtifactTierProvesDoes not prove
Assurance checks (this report)executedCode behaved as specified on the listed inputs on this host and Node version.Behaviour on other inputs, hosts or future versions.
Hash-chained audit.jsonltamper-evidentAccidental or partial edits to the event log are detectable.Authorship, or integrity against an admin who rewrites the whole chain.
Evidence references (SHA-256)digest-onlyFile bytes matched at recording time.That the file content is true, complete or verified by a human.
Owner declarations in registrydeclaredWhat an owner stated.That the statement is accurate.
Repository scan candidatesobservedA declared dependency or MCP entry exists in an allowlisted file.That it runs in production or that the inventory is complete.
Risk scoreheuristicA transparent weighted prioritization of declared inputs.Legal risk category, safety or harm likelihood.

Not tested / not claimed

A SHA-256 seal detects change; it is not a signature and does not prove who produced the report. Only a human maintainer can approve a release.

This is an internal engineering review aid. It is not legal advice, a regulatory classification, a compliance determination, a certification or proof of safety.